Yes, if you slipped on ice in a Queens roadway, crosswalk, or city-controlled sidewalk, you can bring a claim against the City of New York. You must first file a Notice of Claim within 90 days of the fall, and the City is responsible only if it had a reasonable chance to clear the ice and failed to do so.
These claims follow stricter rules than an ordinary personal injury case. At Abaev Law Firm, PLLC, clients often come to our Forest Hills slip and fall lawyers after learning that the deadlines against the City are much shorter than they expected.
Who Is Responsible for Ice on a Queens Street or Sidewalk?
The answer depends on exactly where you fell. The City is not always the right defendant, and going after the wrong party can cost you the case.
| Where you fell | Who is usually responsible |
|---|---|
| Roadway or crosswalk | City of New York |
| Pedestrian ramp at a corner | Often the City, depending on location |
| Sidewalk next to a commercial or multi-family building | Usually the owner of the property next to the sidewalk |
| Sidewalk next to an owner-occupied one- to three-family home | Generally the City |
Where you fell is only one factor in determining liability. The owner of the property next to the sidewalk can be held responsible if their snow or ice removal efforts made the sidewalk more dangerous. If you aren’t sure who controlled the spot where you fell, contact Abaev Law Firm, PLLC for a free review before the 90-day window closes.
The 90-Day Notice of Claim Comes First
You must file your Notice of Claim with the NYC Comptroller’s Office, the city office that handles claims, within 90 days of the fall (General Municipal Law § 50-e). This can be done online, in person, or by registered or certified mail.
The Comptroller’s claims guide also states that a lawsuit must be filed within 1 year and 90 days of the incident, far shorter than the standard three-year personal injury statute of limitations.
What you include in the notice matters. You should describe how the fall happened, where the hazardous condition was located, and what you believe caused it. The City may ask you to explain these details under oath at a hearing as part of its investigation.
The importance of including all relevant details is illustrated in Rubenstein v. City of New York. A woman who fell on an icy pedestrian ramp in Forest Hills first reported that she slipped on ice covered by fresh snow. She later claimed that a recurring sewer backup had flooded the ramp and caused the ice, but the court dismissed her lawsuit because her original Notice of Claim did not mention the sewer problem.
Why Many Ice Claims Against the City Fail
The storm-in-progress rule is the City’s strongest defense. Generally, the City cannot be held liable for failing to remove snow or ice while a storm is underway or before it has had a reasonable time to address the conditions after the storm ends. Weather records, Department of Sanitation plowing logs, and expert testimony can help establish whether the City had enough time to respond.
Your own conduct is also examined. If you were partly at fault, for example by wearing unsuitable shoes or walking over ice you could see, your compensation gets reduced by your share of the blame, but you can still recover.
Write down the date, time, and exact location of your fall, photograph the ice, and keep your medical records. Then call Abaev Law Firm, PLLC for a free consultation; we handle these cases on a contingency fee basis and can file your Notice of Claim well before the deadline.