Your own health insurance usually pays your medical bills first after a slip and fall in Queens. If the property owner was negligent, their insurance company can be required to reimburse those costs through a settlement or trial verdict. Your health plan may then claim part of that recovery for what it paid.
Who ultimately pays depends on where you fell, whether you were working, and who controlled the property. Nissim Abaev, a Forest Hills slip and fall lawyer at Abaev Law Firm, PLLC, helps injured Queens residents sort out which policy pays and when.
Who covers treatment while the case is pending?
Bills arrive long before any claim resolves. Who pays first depends on the circumstances of the fall:
| Situation | Who usually pays first |
|---|---|
| Fall in a store, building or on a sidewalk | Your health insurance, Medicaid or Medicare |
| Fall while on the job | Workers’ compensation |
| Property owner’s policy includes medical payments coverage | That coverage, regardless of fault |
| Fall getting in or out of a vehicle | Possibly no-fault (personal injury protection) benefits |
No-fault insurance applies to motor vehicle accidents, so most slip and fall victims won’t have personal injury protection to draw on. That’s why using your health coverage right away matters.
If you’re unsure which applies, call the injury attorneys at Abaev Law Firm at (212) 763-7738 for a free consultation.
When the property owner’s insurance pays
Under New York premises liability law, owners and those who control property owe visitors a duty of care to keep it reasonably safe. You generally need to show the owner created the hazard or knew, or should have known, about it and failed to fix it. That negligence is what shifts your medical expenses, lost wages, and pain and suffering onto the owner’s insurer.
Proving what the owner knew often depends on evidence such as surveillance footage and maintenance logs. Waiting risks losing it, which can weaken the claim against the insurer.
Sidewalks in New York City follow a specific rule. Administrative Code § 7-210 places liability on the owner of the adjacent property, with an exception for certain owner-occupied one- to three-family homes. If the City itself is responsible, a notice of claim must be filed within 90 days.
Comparative negligence also shapes how much the owner’s insurer pays. New York lets you recover even if you were partly at fault, but your award is reduced by your share. An insurance adjuster will often argue you weren’t watching your step to push that share higher during settlement negotiation.
What happens to health insurance liens when you settle?
If your health insurance, Medicare, or Medicaid paid your bills, they may ask to be repaid out of your settlement. Medicare and Medicaid almost always have that right. New York law limits when many private health insurers can do this, but some employer health plans follow federal rules instead and may still ask for repayment. A lawyer can check which rules apply to your plan
Filing deadlines and Queens Supreme Court
Most slip and fall lawsuits against private owners must be filed within New York’s personal injury statute of limitations, which is generally three years from the date of the accident. Larger cases are typically filed in Queens Supreme Court. Until then, keep every bill, insurance statement, and photo of the hazard, and let a lawyer match each cost to the right payer.
Contact our slip and fall attorneys at (212) 763-7738 to schedule a free, no-obligation case review.