Sometimes, yes. A Queens landlord who controls the building is generally responsible for icy conditions they created or knew about and failed to fix within a reasonable time. The answer can change if your lease made you responsible for snow removal, if the landlord gave up control of the property, or if you fell on a public sidewalk rather than the building’s own steps or walkway.
At Abaev Law Firm, PLLC, our Forest Hills slip and fall attorneys handle these questions for tenants across Queens. Because the outcome usually depends on facts like who controlled the spot where you fell and what the lease says, it helps to understand how New York courts approach them.
When does a landlord owe you a duty to clear ice?
A landlord who manages the building, hires the super, and handles common areas owes tenants a legal duty to keep entrances, stairs, and walkways reasonably safe.
A landlord who has handed over control of the property, for example by leasing the whole building to someone else who runs it, may have a defense. However, simply being an “out-of-possession landlord” does not automatically eliminate liability. Courts may still consider whether the landlord retained responsibility for repairs or had a duty to address the condition.
Lease terms may make tenants responsible for clearing snow and ice, but that does not automatically relieve landlords of responsibility for dangerous conditions caused by poor property maintenance. For example, if a leaking roof or clogged gutter drips melting snow onto an entrance step where it refreezes, the landlord may still be liable if they were responsible for maintaining the building’s exterior and knew or should have known about the problem.
If you aren’t sure who controlled the area where you fell, call Abaev Law Firm, PLLC at (212) 763-7738 for a free consultation, or reach our slip and fall team online.
Who may be responsible depends on where you fell
The location of the fall often decides which rules apply.
| Where you fell | Who may be responsible | What can change it |
|---|---|---|
| Interior stairs or lobby | Landlord or property management company | Whether they had notice of the ice |
| Building’s exterior steps or walkway | Landlord in possession | Lease snow clauses, out-of-possession status |
| Ice from a leaking gutter or roof | Owner responsible for repairs | Proof the defect caused the ice |
| Public sidewalk beside the building | Owner, if a law imposes liability | NYC Administrative Code rules by building type |
Sidewalks are the trickiest category. Generally, property owners are not responsible for naturally accumulated snow and ice on public sidewalks unless a law specifically imposes liability.
In New York City, Administrative Code § 7-210 shifts responsibility for sidewalk maintenance to many building owners, including owners of commercial and multifamily properties. However, certain owner-occupied one-, two-, and three-family homes are generally exempt.
Separately, Administrative Code § 16-123 requires owners and others in charge of a building to clear snow and ice from the adjoining sidewalk within a set time after the snow stops, generally four hours during the day and longer when it stops in the evening or overnight. Violating § 16-123 does not by itself make someone liable for your injuries, but the deadline can help show whether the owner had a reasonable amount of time to act.
What you need to prove, and how fast
You generally must show the landlord was responsible for the accumulated ice or had notice of it and didn’t act, for example, by failing to shovel or apply ice melt. Courts also look at whether a storm was still in progress. New York’s comparative negligence rule can reduce, but not eliminate, your recovery if you share some fault.
Gather this evidence early:
- Photos of the ice, the surrounding area, and any gutters or downspouts. Ice melts and conditions can change within hours, so pictures taken soon after the fall may be the only record of what the spot looked like, and a shot of a dripping gutter can point to a structural cause the landlord is responsible for
- Your lease
- Names of neighbors or building staff who saw the icy condition
- Prior complaints to the landlord or super
- Medical records, starting with the day of the fall and continuing through your treatment
Timing is strict. Most negligence claims fall under a three-year deadline (CPLR 214), and claims involving city property carry much shorter notice-of-claim deadlines.
If you slipped on ice at your Queens building, preserve your photos and lease, then call Abaev Law Firm, PLLC at (212) 763-7738 to schedule a free, no-obligation case review.